spelling 2 min read

who had contraction

Who had contracts to who'd, pronounced /huːd/.

A closer look

who'd /huːd/ is the contraction of who had (it also stands for who would). The apostrophe replaces ha in had; spelling it whod drops a required mark. The long /uː/ stays even though the written form shrinks. She asked who'd left the door open.

  • They found out who'd taken the last slice works because who'd can stand for who had before a past participle.

  • Nobody knew who'd been sitting in my chair. The apostrophe is doing its job here, and /huːd/ rhymes with food, mood and rude, all long /uː/ plus a final /d/.

  • Notice the sound: the /d/ at the end of who'd belongs to the contracted word itself, so nothing extra is pronounced for had.

  • A quick check you can trust: if who had fits naturally in the sentence, who'd is the right spelling.

The apostrophe also guards against a spelling mix-up. Without it, whod is exactly how the word whodunit, the informal word for a crime story, begins. One glance at whod can send a reader down the wrong path, so keep the mark: it shows that letters were dropped from had and keeps the contraction visually separate from the story word.

The sound gives you no clue about the meaning. /huːd/ with its long /uː/ is identical whichever expansion applies, so readers recover who had or who would from the grammar around it, not from the ear.

All articles